What do you think of these banners?

Well im still new to photoshop, but i have been doing banners for some people.

Tell me what you think, any feedback good or bad.
and please rate them 1-10

This is my first ever banner(wasent for a person)
#1

Now, im doing stuff like these.

#2

#3

and my latest (not yet done)

#4

 

7/10 Very nice.

 

thanks, what is it that you like?

 

Not bad, keep learning how to use typography, color combination, filter, layer overlay, color gradient etc.

 

A bit more work on the color combination, the fonts and the layout... you'll definitely get better. Just my opinion...

 

so far i like #3

 

I like the second most LEARN ME HOW TO ANIMATE! Ive got photoshop cs3 for a couple of months now, and i still cant animate >.>

 

Not to bad #4 seems too big though.

 

Thanks for the imput, i never use filters. ill give it a try

Thanks. Do you know a good place for quality fonts?

Me too, lol

Pm sent

Its the size he wanted.

 

I like it i think that the only thing is missing for this banners to rock is just a little more color contrast

 

I figured that out, if you look at #1 and #2 i have started to mix colors more

 

I prefer #2 because the color combination fits and typography is unified.

The other banners use too many and too different font types.

 

Firstly im no designer so i understand im not in a position to now whats good or not but il give my honest opinion, their all not bad.

The first one, its clear and easy to read, would blend in without blinding 7

The next one, not bad as well, id say a 6

THe third, i recognise the name quite good, the green is teenie bit bright for me but still good 7

 

Very plain. Take a look at some other peoples advertisement banners. But you'll get it, im sure.

 

#3 has only 2 types of fonts.
Do you really think that too many?

Thanks, I was thinking 1 would be the worst.

Thanks.
Im still learning different thing. But the banners were made for people without logos. Thats why they are soo plain.

 

Not "clean" enough.

 

goooddd.....

 

Good stuff. Definitely take the advice of what people have been saying here. I would recommend finding some Photoshop Tutorial books and learning more about what Photoshop is capable, because let me tell you, it is capable of a LOT!